the products are great and i love all the colors! i bought them because of the “tarte maracuja lip dupes” and have to say: these are more balms, then glosses! they are not nearly as thick as the tarte ones and have only about 60%-70% as much shine. i honestly wouldn’t call them a dupes, but still a great products on its own. i love the option of being able to buy all of them and the colors are gorgeous